Alright, let’s talk about finding that killer fantasy baseball name. It sounds easy, right? But man, when you sit down to actually do it, your brain just kinda… stalls out.

So, I joined this new league with some buddies, pretty competitive group. Needed a solid name. My old one, something lame like ‘Baseball Bonanza’, just wasn’t cutting it anymore. Felt stale, you know? Time for a refresh.
Getting Started (The Blank Page Phase)
First thing I did? Just stared at my empty team page. That blinking cursor is intimidating. My initial thoughts were all over the place. Should I go with a pun? Something tough-sounding? Reference my favorite player? My brain went blank.
I started jotting down some real basic stuff. Like, player names mashed together. Think, uh, ‘Troutstanding Judge’? Terrible. Absolutely awful. Crossed that out immediately. Tried combining team names with weird adjectives. ‘Grumpy Yankees’? ‘Sleepy Dodgers’? Nope. This was harder than drafting the actual team.
The Grind – Trying Different Angles
Okay, plan B. I thought about my favorite players. Maybe a pun on their name? That seemed promising. I spent a good chunk of time just listing players:
- Shohei Ohtani
- Aaron Judge
- Mookie Betts
- Ronald Acuña Jr.
- Mike Trout
Then I tried twisting their names. ‘Ohtani Kanobi’? Getting warmer, but maybe too nerdy for this league. ‘All Rise for the Judge’? Kinda common. ‘Betts Off’? Eh. ‘Acuña Matata’? Okay, that one got a chuckle. Added it to the maybe list.

Then I pivoted. Forget player names for a second. What about just funny baseball terms or situations? ‘Multiple Scoregasms’ always gets a laugh, but it’s super played out. ‘Bad News Bears’? Classic, but again, not original. ‘Darryl Strawberry’s Tax Service’? A bit niche, maybe?
I even thought about inside jokes with my friends in the league, but nothing really fit the ‘awesome’ category. It just felt… forced.
Finding the Groove
Honestly, I stepped away for a bit. Grabbed a drink, put on some music. Stopped trying so hard. Sometimes that’s the best way, right? Let the background processes in your brain do the work.
And then it kinda clicked. I wasn’t aiming for the funniest name ever, or the cleverest. I just wanted something that sounded cool, was unique to me, and maybe had a slight edge. I thought back to some of my favorite players, not just the superstars.
I landed on focusing on a slightly less common player pun or a reference that wasn’t beaten to death. I revisited my list, played around with some phrasing. Said a few out loud. Yeah, I actually talked to myself. Judge me if you want, it helps!
Settling on One (or a Few Good Ones)
After all that brainstorming and talking to myself, I narrowed it down. ‘Acuña Matata’ was still a strong contender because it’s just fun. But I also liked stuff related to pitching. Maybe something like ‘Sale of the Century’ (if I had Chris Sale) or ‘Strider Things’ (big fan of Spencer Strider’s mustache, honestly).
In the end, I picked one that felt right for this team and this league. I won’t bore you with the absolute final choice because, hey, gotta keep some mystery for my league mates. But the process involved a lot more dead ends and bad puns than I expected.
It’s funny how much mental energy goes into something seemingly trivial. But hey, your team name is your identity for the whole season. Gotta make it count, or at least make it something you don’t hate by May.